Tuesday, 24 June 2014

Changes to the right to request flexible working

On 30 June 2014, the Flexible Working Regulations are amended. This will have a significant impact upon businesses and their employees.

What are the key points at present in relation to flexible working?

  • Employees must have 26 weeks continuous employment
  • Employers have to by law consider applications
  • An employee can appeal against a refusal by an employer
  • An agreement can be negotiated
  • One application is allowed every 12 months
  • Parents with children aged 16 or under (18 if disabled) and certain carers can apply
What are the key changes?
  • The request can now be made by an employee with 26 weeks service
  • The application need not be linked to children or care requirements
  • The employer is not legally obliged to consider the matter but must consider the request in a reasonable manner 
  • Employers have more flexibility to refuse requests on business grounds
What should I do as a reasonable employer?

The first thing any employer needs to do is to update their policies in relation to flexible working. This will include ensuring that staff are aware as to how they can make an application, how any when meetings will take place, how and when appeals will be heard and that the employer will fairly consider all requests.

How to handle a request
  • Acknowledge the request and send the employee a letter confirming this
  • Send the employee a copy of the policy document
  • Have a meeting/discussion if the request cannot be agreed upon receipt 
  • Allow the employee to be accompanied to any meeting (good practice not a requirement) 
How to decide a request

Consider the affect upon the business and balance these against the benefit to the employee. Consider any cost implications.

On what grounds can an application be refused?
  • Additional costs to the business
  • Inability to organise other staff
  • Impact upon quality
  • Impact upon customer demand
  • Impact upon performance
  • Planned changes to the business
Summary

As with any change to any law, it is unclear whether these changes will have a significant effect upon employers and indeed employee in the workplace. However, it is imperative that employers are aware of these changes and how they should deal with any requests in the future. 

The above comments are not intended to be specific legal advice upon any particular set of facts and should not be relied upon for the same. If in doubt, an employer or an employee should seek legal advice. If you wish to discuss this or any other employment issue further then please contact us on 01582 439795.

For more information upon employment law issues sign up to our regular employment and HR bulletin here.
http://bit.ly/1dOy3jl

Monday, 23 June 2014

How do we conduct a disciplinary hearing?

From time to time, disciplinary issues arise in any workplace. They need to be dealt with fairly, consistently and promptly. Any Company should, in any event, have disciplinary procedures in place that are up to date with present legislation.

What is the first step to take?
The first step in any process is to identify the issue involved and to investigate. It may be that poor performance, for example, is down to a lack of training or supervision and therefore can easily be resolved by intervention and guidance rather than by disciplinary action. An investigation meeting can be held to establish the facts. Witnesses can be identified and statements can be taken.

If there is a case to answer what do we do next?
The next step is to send the employee what is commonly known as a 'step one' letter. This should set out what the issue involved is and when and where the meeting will take place. Reasonable notice should be given and a copy of the evidence included. the employee must be told that he can be accompanied and that if he persistently fails to attend meetings, the matter may proceed in his absence. The letter should also indicate if dismissal is a possible sanction.

Who should conduct a hearing?
The hearing should be conducted by a senior manager who has authority to make any appropriate decision. It should not be the same person who conducted the investigation.

How should the hearing proceed?
Notes should be taken and agreed if possible. The hearing can even be recorded and a transcript prepared. The employer should present their case and witness statements can be read. Alternatively, witnesses can be called to give evidence. Questions can be asked of witnesses. The employee will then present his or her case and will be given the opportunity of calling witnesses.

When should the decision be made?
In very straightforward cases the decision can be made there and then. The person chairing the meeting can take as long as they require and may wish to consider the matter overnight. Each case will depend upon its facts.

What happens next?
The employee should be notified in writing of any findings made and the decision arrived at. They should also be told of their right to appeal against the decision to a more senior manager.

Summary

  • Investigate thoroughly
  • Send a 'step one' letter
  • Right to be accompanied
  • Make notes and agree them
  • Come to a decision and justify it in writing
  • Remind the employee of their right to appeal

This article gives our thoughts on how a disciplinary process may proceed.It is not meant to be advice on any particular set of facts. If in doubt legal advice should always be sought. We have considerable experience in employment and HR issues and can be contacted on 01582 439795.  

Friday, 6 June 2014

Zero Hours Contracts - What's all the fuss about

What is a zero hours contract
A zero hours contract is where an employee is retained on a contract of employment but is not guaranteed any actual hours of work by his employer. This means that the employer has flexibility in when he calls upon the services of the employee.

What about the employee
The employee may also benefit from such a contract. A student, retired person or housewife may welcome the flexibility of working when and if they choose. However, some zero hours contracts require the employee to be available to work for the employer during certain hours, which is clearly a step too far. This can lead to an employee turning down other work only to sit at home awaiting their employer's call only to receive no such call and therefore no income for that day.

How did such contracts come about
The truth is that this type of contract has been around for many years and has been commonly used in the food business as well as in tourism. A restaurant for example may have a very quiet day and will want to therefore have the flexibility to send staff home or to ask staff not to come in. Similarly, a theme park or tourist attraction will require far more staff when the weather is good and will also want the flexibility to have less staff working if circumstances and the British weather dictates.

What therefore is the issue
The controversy with such contracts is that they have now been adopted as the norm by many national firms and companies on the high street. It is arguable that many of these companies do not need and cannot justify such contracts. However, they merely use them as they provide the absolute minimum in employment rights to staff and you can in essence achieve a workforce of agency staff without the costs involved in recruiting via an agency. 

Should such contracts be outlawed
In our view no. However, they should be used far less than they actually are and an employer should have to justify their use if required to do so.

This blog is designed to share our views on zero hours contracts. It is not intended as legal advice and should not be read as. If you wish to discuss zero hours contracts or indeed any employment law issue then please call us on 01582 439795.

Our website is www.chilternsolicitors.co.uk or follow us on twitter @chilternsols.

 

Can we proceed in absence if an employee does not attend a disciplinary hearing?

An employee may choose not to attend a scheduled disciplinary hearing. This is generally for one of two reasons. The first reason is that the employee does not want to face up to the matter in question. As such, they may simply refuse to attend any meeting or they may go off work and claim that they are sick with stress or something similar. This does not of course mean that every employee who is off work sick with stress is not suffering from the same.

The second reason is because of illness. What happens next will very much depend upon the type of illness and how long the employee is likely to be off work sick.

How do we invite the employee to a meeting?
As with any disciplinary hearing, it is important to write to the employee and advise them of what the issue is that you wish to discuss with them. They should also be advised as to whether the likely sanction will include dismissal.

The first letter should advise the employee that if they fail to attend the disciplinary hearing it will be adjourned on the first occasion. If they fail to attend a second hearing then the matter may proceed in their absence on the evidence available to the employer.

What if the employee fails to attend?
If we assume that the employee does not attend then the employer needs to consider the reason for non-attendance. If the employee is at work and simply will not follow a request to attend a meeting then he or she needs to be reminded that it is a reasonable request and the failure to follow such a request may lead to further disciplinary action being taken.

In the case of a failure to attend because of sickness the employer will need to consider the illness complained of and how this may impact upon the disciplinary process. Key features will include:

  • the type of illness and whether this affects the employee's ability to participate in a meeting.
  • the likely duration of the illness and the impact upon the business of continued absence.
  • whether any reasonable adjustments can be made to the disciplinary process to allow matters to proceed.
Should we obtain medical evidence?
It is always advisable to obtain medical evidence in all but the most obvious of cases. This should include questions such as how long the illness complained of is likely to last, whether the person can attend a meeting and what adjustments can be made to allow a meeting to take place.
It is important to note that an employee does not have to consent to such a report being prepared and they can withhold their consent even after they have seen any report. If this happens then the employee should be reminded that the employer will proceed on the evidence available.

What if the employee fails to attend a second meeting?
If this happens then the employer may choose to proceed on the evidence available at that time. They may wish to allow the employee to make written representations or make other adjustments to the process. Whether or not the employer should proceed in absence will depend upon a number of factors including:
  • the employee, their work record, disciplinary record, position and length of service
  • the seriousness of the allegation and whether dismissal is an option
  • any medical opinion and how long the absence will last for
  • how cases such as this have been considered in the past
  • what the disciplinary procedures say about proceeding in absence
  • whether the employer genuinely believes that the employee is trying to avoid or delay the process    
Matters such as this really rely upon a little common sense. If for example there is a second meeting on the Tuesday and the employee has flu but will be back on the Friday then it makes no sense to proceed in absence. However, if the employee has a broken wrist and fails to attend a number of meetings, the employer may feel that the broken wrist does not impact upon the employee's ability to take part in a meeting and that the matter should proceed.

Summary of key points
  • Write and advise of the issue of proceeding in absence
  • Always consider obtaining medical evidence
  • Consider the matter fairly and ask how an outsider may view the decision to proceed - was it reasonable in the circumstances.
This blog represent our thoughts on disciplinary matters being held in the absence of an employee. It is not meant to be taken as specific legal advice nor should it be applied to any particular set of facts. If in doubt always seek legal advice in such matters.

We have considerable experience in advising employers on disciplinary matters and can be contacted on 01582 439795.

For more information see our website at www.chilternsolicitors.co.uk or follow us on twitter @chilternsols



Friday, 25 April 2014

What are common mistakes made when dismissing employees?

There are a number of common mistakes made by employers which can lead to a finding of unfair dismissal by an employment tribunal. Whilst this may not lead to a significant award of compensation if it can be argued that the employer would have been entitled to dismiss in any even, it can still lead to unnecessary time and costs being incurred. Most mistakes are down to ignorance of the law or lack of planning and can easily be avoided.


  1. Ensure that a disciplinary hearing is held. Do not dismiss without holding a disciplinary hearing.
  2. Carry out an investigation into what happened prior to coming to the decision to discipline in all but the most obvious of cases.
  3. Write to the employee and tell them what the issue is. Tell them whether dismissal is a possible sanction.
  4. Remind the employee of his or her right to be accompanied by a colleague or trade union official.
  5. Provide the employee with the evidence that has been gathered as a result of the investigation.
  6. Ensure that the employee has sufficient notice of the hearing. At least one or two working days is ideal.
  7. Make sure that the person conducting the disciplinary hearing was not involved in the investigation.
  8. Listen to all of the evidence and allow the employee to present their case.
  9. Take time in coming to any decision to dismiss. There is no need to rush any decision.
  10. If the employee fails to attend on the first occasion adjourn matters. You can usually proceed on the second occasion subject to certain provisions.
  11. Inform the employee in writing of the reason for dismissal and any findings made. If, for example, the employer relies upon a loss of trust and confidence state why such a loss has arisen.
  12. Always remind the employee of their right to appeal the decision and ensure that the appeal is heard by a more senior manager.
  13. Be consistent. If one employee has been dismissed for a certain act whereas a colleague has not then there should be good reasons for this.
In summary
  • Carefully plan how you intend to deal with any disciplinary issue.
  • Be aware of your own procedures and follow them.If you have no procedures then prepare some.
  • If in doubt always seek legal advice before dismissing.
This blog sets out our thoughts on avoiding unfair dismissal claims. It is not specific legal advice on any particular set of facts and should not be taken as such. If in doubt seek legal advice. We are able to provide a HR system to employers that will provide you with all of the assistance that you need in dealing with staffing issues. Feel free to call us on 01582 439795. 

Thursday, 24 April 2014

How to manage sickness absence in the workplace

Sickness absence can vary significantly from case to case. It can cover anything from an employee who suffers a broken leg to an employee who appears to take a lot of Mondays off work. How the matter is dealt with will very much depend upon the type of case.

Dealing with periods of short term absence
If an employee is absent for a number of occasions on short term sickness then the employer needs to consider the absence level of the employee and whether there is any pattern to the same. If the same day of the week is taken off or a lot of sickness happens before or after bank holiday then this suggests that there is likely to be an issue.

Investigating the matter and the disciplinary process
In such a case, the employer needs to follow the disciplinary process and firstly investigate the matter to see if there is a case to answer. This will involve the employee being called to a meeting to explain why he is absent on many Mondays. If there is no satisfactory explanation then the matter will proceed to a disciplinary hearing.

If the disciplinary hearing finds that the absences are not acceptable then the employee should receive a warning. It will not normally be justified to dismiss without previous warning having been given for similar conduct. Always remember the right of appeal.

How to gain improvement in attendance
The outcome letter should state that the level of sickness is not acceptable and that improvement is required. However, this in itself is not enough. If an employee has 20 days off work sick and is warned to improve then has 19 days off sick he cannot be disciplined again as he has in fact improved as requested. The employer needs to calculate the average days taken off sick by the rest of the workforce and come to a conclusion of what is acceptable.

Does this mean that any further absence over and above this level will lead to dismissal
Normally an employee will need to be on a final written warning to be dismissed. However, even if this is the case, there may be circumstances where it is not appropriate to dismiss such as cases of genuine and accepted illness.

Dealing with periods of long term absence
If long term absence is an issue, the employer may wish to dismiss on the basis of capability in that the employee cannot carry out his or her role and that, as such the contract is frustrated (can no longer be effective).

How should the matter proceed
If an employee is on long term sickness then the employee needs firstly to carry out an investigation into the absence. This investigation should consider:

  • the nature of the illness and the effect on the employee to carry out their role
  • when or if the employee is likely to be able to return to work
  • the work record of the employee and how other cases have been dealt with
  • whether any reasonable adjustments to the role can be made or if there is an alternative role 
Is medical evidence required
Medical evidence should always be requested in such cases. The doctor can be asked to consider the above issues. It is always advisable to contact an independent doctor rather than the employee's own doctor. 

Does the employee have to consent to a medical report
The employee does not have to consent to a report being prepared and, if they see the report, they can request that it is not shown to the employer. They should be made aware that if there is no report then the employer will proceed on the evidence available.

What if we decide to proceed
The employer should then write to the employee stating that a meeting will take place to consider whether the employee is capable of continuing in their role. They should be provided with all of the evidence available and be reminded of their right to be accompanied to the meeting by a work colleague or union official.

Making the decision
The decision is a difficult one as it may involve terminating the employment of an otherwise helpful employee who through no fault of his or her own cannot attend work. The key issue here is how long the absence will last for and whether the business can cope with the absence of the employee in question. The more the impact upon the business and the more difficult the absence is for the employer to deal with the easier it will be to justify dismissal.
As with any dismissal there is a right of appeal and the employee should be notified of the reason in writing and how the decision was reached.

Summary

  • For short term sickness give a chance to improve to agreed levels
  • For long term sickness try to obtain medical evidence and consider the impact upon the company 
  • Follow the disciplinary and appeals process in either case  
  • Act reasoanbly and be prepared to justify any decision

This blog is our thoughts on sickness absence. It is not meant as specific advice and should not be taken as such. It should not be applied to any particular set of facts. If in doubt always seek legal advice. We are experts in employment law and HR issues and can be contacted on 01582 439795. 

Wednesday, 23 April 2014

Do we need to provide a written contract of employment?

All employees have a contract of employment. Verbal contracts have the same legal status as a written contract but are more difficult to prove. The terms of the contract can be express or implied and can be provided by statute.

An express term is something that is usually in writing but can also be verbally agreed. This is something such as the hourly or weekly rate of pay. An implied term is something that is not in the contract that is written or verbally agreed but still exists. For example, it may be an implied term of the contract that the employer provides the employee with free tea, coffee and biscuits. Another implied term is that of mutual trust and confidence. This means that the parties will act reasonably towards one another.

When should a contract of employment be issued?
It is always safer to issue written particulars of employment. In doing so there is certainty as to what has been agreed and what each party can expect of the other. An employee is entitled to receive a written statement of their particulars of employment within two months of commencement of employment.

What should this contain?

  • the name and address of each party
  • the date of employment commencing and details of continuous employment
  • rate and frequency of pay
  • hours of work
  • holidays
  • sick pay
  • pensions
  • job title or description
  • place of work and mobility clause
  • length of notice required
  • if fixed term contract date employment will cease 
  • details of any collective agreement
  • details of work outside UK
  • disciplinary and grievance issues
What else can the contract contain?
The contract can contain any other issues that the parties agree and view as being right to include in the contract. The employer may wish to include a policy on equal opportunities, what it views as gross misconduct or indeed policies designed to protect the company upon termination such as restrictive covenants. These can prevent staff being solicited and customers being approached and poached by a disgruntled employee. It is also possible to prevent an employee from working within a certain geographical area.

What are the minimum implied terms of employment?
Mutual trust and confidence is key. Any employee and employer must act fairly towards one another. The parties must act in good faith and the parties cannot act unreasonably. The employee will be expected not to disclose trade secrets, take care of equipment and obey reasonable orders.   

Summary
  • Whilst a contract of employment should always be in writing it can be as brief or as thorough as is required by the particular role.
  • Always provide the contract within the relevant time allowed.
  • Review the contract so as to comply with legislation changes. 
  • Review the contract if the role changes significantly.
  • Take great care when trying to vary the terms of the contract if the employee is not in agreement. 

This article is intended to provide our thoughts on contracts of employment. It is not meant to be specific advice on any particular employment matter. If in doubt always seek legal advice. We are experienced in drafting contracts of employment and can be contacted on 01582 439795.