Monday, 1 December 2014

Holiday pay and commission - how does one affect the other?

There have been a number of recent cases on holiday pay and how payments of commission and overtime may influence what an employee is paid when they are on holiday. We have written a separate blog on the issue of holiday and overtime which we invite you to also read.

For many years, companies have tended to pay employees their normal weekly rate when they have been on holiday. This has meant that many staff who may receive a low basic wage and large sums of commission are significantly affected financially when they take holiday leave. Indeed, this may mean that staff choose not to take all of their holiday entitlement.

The problem
The main problem with holiday pay is that the government who introduced the Working Time Regulations did not set out how a week's pay should be calculated. This led to employers relying upon the definition in the Employment Rights Act of the normal rate of pay or, if this varies, the average pay over a twelve week period.

Lock v British Gas
This case is now the main authority for holiday pay and commission. Mr Lock was a salesman. More than half of his salary was commission.  He took his case to Europe and successfully argued that his holiday pay should take into consideration his commission payments. The Court stated that if a person earns far less in wages when they are on holiday, they will be less likely to take holiday. This defeats the purpose of employment legislation guaranteeing a certain amount of holiday entitlement to employees of member states.

Where does this now leave us?
With immediate effect, all employers should be calculating holiday pay in accordance with the Lock decision and therefore including commission in such payments. The Lock case has been referred back to the UK Tribunals to decide whether commission should be calculated over the 12 weeks before the holiday is taken or the preceding 12 months. The European Court seems to prefer the 12 month approach but employers may wish to adopt the 12 week approach until matters are final clarified in 2015. 
Employers must however act now and cannot simply wait for the UK Tribunal to decide whether the relevant period is 12 weeks or 12 months.

This blog sets out the law as we see it in relation to holiday pay and commission. It is not intended to be specific legal advice in relation to an employer or employee and must not be relied upon a such. If in doubt any person should always seek legal advice.

We have written a separate blog on holiday pay and overtime and hope you will take a look at that as well. We love to read your comments upon our blogs. Please feel free to therefore leave your thoughts and comments.

Chiltern Solicitors is a specialist employment law practice which offers a wide range of services to both employers and employees. We are particularly proud of our HR service for employers called Chiltern HR. For more details call our team on 01582 439795 or email info@chilternsolicitors.co.uk

Thanks for reading.

Tuesday, 18 November 2014

Staff Christmas Parties - Don't let your business suffer a New Year hangover with an ET claim

We all love Christmas, the opportunity to let our hair down and have a few days off to spend with friends and family. However, the staff Christmas party can often lead to issues arising between members of staff that need to be either nipped in the bud or prevented from happening in the first place. Many people know an employee who has experienced issues at such parties.

There are a number of things that any employer needs to be aware of when contemplating arranging such a party. Staff also need clear directions on what is expected of them or, more importantly, what is not expected of them.

Invitation to attend
Clearly all staff need to be invited to attend. Some staff may not celebrate Christmas and may not wish to attend. If this is the case then they should be given the opportunity of taking time off rather than attending. The same may also apply to other staff who may just choose not to attend. Staff cannot be forced to attend and enjoy themselves. We have all worked with 'the office misery' from time to time!

Location
It is important that all staff understand that the location of the office party is unimportant. It is still a 'works event' and will be viewed as an extension of the workplace. This was confirmed in the case of Stubbs, which involved off duty police officers at a works social event. Behaviour should therefore be similar to that expected in the workplace. This clearly means no inappropriate behaviour etc which may upset other members of staff, especially those of the opposite sex.

Guidelines
Let staff know if there is a dress code and that their behaviour needs to reflect the fact that this is an official works event. Further, any issues of unacceptable behaviour will be dealt with under the company disciplinary and grievance procedures. Ensure these procedures are up to date as many employers are still relying upon out of date procedures.

Alcohol
If staff are drinking alcohol then the employer needs to ensure that staff are not driving either on the day of the event or indeed the following day.  It may be sensible to have the event on a day when people are not getting up to travel to work early on the following day. The employer may wish to provide transport for staff so as to ensure that all arrive home safely. Finally, it is important to remember that not all staff drink alcohol so plenty of soft drink alternatives should be available. The same will apply to food and ensuring that people's individual dietary requirements are catered for.

Poor behaviour
If there is a problem with behaviour then it is best to get the person or persons to leave. Any disciplinary issues can be dealt with after the holidays. If any grievances are raised about behaviour it is important that these are not dismissed out of hand and that they are dealt with properly and in accordance with company procedures. Poor behaviour can involve office gossip some weeks later. In the case of Nixon, an employee of a solicitors firm was held to have been constructively dismissed and indeed discriminated against as a result of such gossip.

Summary

  • Enjoy Christmas and any office party but be sensible and ensure your staff know what is expected.
  • If you are seen to be reasonable and plan matters hopefully your staff will act in a similar fashion.
  • If there are problems don't say something stupid whilst under the influence of alcohol. Send the people in question home and give yourself time to form a view on how to deal with the matter when you have a clear head.

This blog represents the views of the author and is not intended as specific legal advice on any particular issue and should not be treated as such. If in doubt always seek legal advice. 

Please leave your comments or questions as we welcome feedback. 

If you wish to discuss any employment law issue then please get in touch with us at info@chilternsolicitors.co.uk or call us anytime on 01582 439795. We have a specialist HR package for SME's which is designed to safeguard your business against any potential staffing issues.

Friday, 7 November 2014

We need to discipline a member of staff but have no idea where to start

Not knowing how to discipline staff can be a real issue for both smaller and larger employers. Even employers with dedicated HR staff often make very basic mistakes which can prove costly. So where do you need to start.

Disciplinary and grievance procedures
The first thing that any employer needs to be aware of is the need to have a procedure written down for dealing with such matters. It is also important to keep this up to date. We have seen many documents in recent years that have not been updated and do not comply with the latest ACAS codes.

Agree who will deal with matters
Ideally, the process can involve up to three people.The first person will carry out the investigation and establish so far as possible what has occurred. They will see the member of staff in question and will speak to other members of staff and other witnesses. This person will then decide how the matter will proceed.

Write to the person inviting them to a meeting
This does not have to be done but is good practice and will impress a tribunal if matters ever go that far. The letter should point out that if the person does not attend then the investigation may proceed without them.

Hold a meeting
There is no right to be accompanied at this first meeting. This is a fact finding exercise. However, notes should be taken and agreed if possible.

Decide what actions is necessary
The investigation decides if the matter proceeds any further and if so, on what basis. For example, if the company has a history of giving a final written warning for people who use their mobile phones whilst driving on company business they cannot suddenly dismiss a member of staff without good reason as he will be able to argue that the decision is unfair as others have been treated differently in very similar circumstances.

Write a 'step one' letter
The step one letter tells a person why they are being subjected to disciplinary proceedings. Do not be at all vague in this letter. It is important that an employee knows what the issue is and what evidence this is based upon so that they can prepare properly for the meeting. They are entitled to be accompanied by a work colleague or approved trade union official. Make sure that the letter gives sufficient notice. We would suggest no less than two working days. The letter should make it clear whether or not dismissal is an option.

Hold the disciplinary meeting
Ideally, the investigator will present the case for the employer and will produce minutes of the meeting and all of the witness statements. Witnesses can give evidence for both sides. The employee should be allowed to ask questions and sum up his or her case. Do not rush into any decision. If more information is required then obtain it and reconvene at a later date. Take minutes and get these agreed.

Give reasons for any decision in writing and outline what findings were made
The person making the decision should be prepared to make findings as to fact. For example if the misconduct is fighting in the workplace and the employee argues that he acted in self-defence, the person conducting the decision should be prepared to make a decision upon whether this explanation was accepted or not as the case may be. The findings will not usually be questioned by a tribunal so long as they are seen as reasonable and that the matter was given due consideration.

Be prepared to have an appeal
Any employer who is dismissed will normally appeal against the decision. After all, they have little to lose in doing so. The appeal should be heard by a more senior member of staff with authority to overturn the decision. We have been involved in a case whereby a junior manager was allowed to conduct the appeal and admitted in evidence that he knew he could not overturn his boss's decision to dismiss. Needless to say our client won his claim for unfair dismissal. The same guidance applies as to being accompanied and taking minutes.

What if you don't have three staff who can deal with such matters
Any employment tribunal will always consider the size and resources available to any employer when dealing with such matters. This means that, technically, if there is the business owner and a small number of employees then the owner may carry out the investigation, disciplinary hearing and appeal. However, they would be better advised to involve at least one other person in the process such as the company solicitor, accountant or another business owner.

Summary
Preparation and good procedures in place are key. If you fail to plan then you are planning to fail has never been truer than in disciplinary issues.

The above comments are the thoughts of the author and are not to be taken as being legal advice on any particular issue. if in doubt always seek legal advice.

At Chiltern Solicitors, we are happy to speak to you at any time on employment and staffing issues. Call us on 01582 439795 or email info@chilternsolicitors.co.uk. We have a regular HR and employment bulletin providing regular and helpful employment advice to all businesses. Drop us a line to subscribe to future issues.

Wednesday, 17 September 2014

Why should employers ensure good personnel records are kept

Personnel records are key to any business. Whether an employer has two staff or two hundred there is simply no excuse for not keeping good staffing records. If ever there is an issue, these can become invaluable should an employment issue arise. Further, they can be used as evidence in tribunal proceedings to defend claims for unfair dismissal.

Quite often an employer will speak to a member of staff about their employment. This could be to do with a wide range of issues such as turning up late, poor performance or taking too many sick days. Having good records will make carrying out disciplinary proceedings so much easier. It can also assist in issues of redundancy where the employer is seeking to keep the better staff and be able to justify who he chooses to keep and who he chooses to let go.

What records need to be kept

  • any issues of attending late or unauthorised absence.
  • any minor acts of misconduct or poor performance that are not formally dealt with.
  • levels of sickness absence.
  • any complaints against the member of staff by colleagues.
  • any type of appraisal used.
  • if the employee is praised for good performance.
Why are these issues key
  • employees are now more aware of their rights and are likely to appeal disciplinary findings and dismissals.
  • it allows the employer to build up an approach that shows consistency and fairness in dealing with staff.
  • most importantly it allows for employers to justify their findings to a tribunal and defend any claim an employee may make against them.
  • many employment tribunal cases are won or lost on the quality of the procedures adopted by the employer. Any tribunal chairman will be looking at these procedures closely. Decent procedures and consistency in approach points towards a fair minded employer who is more likely to be supported by a tribunal.
What do I need to do as an employer
  • Introduce systems for dealing with issues such as absence and poor performance.
  •  Make sure staff who are entrusted with dealing with these matters are well trained and understand the issues involved and what is required.
  • Keep good records and be prepared to produce these to the tribunal and to be able to justify decisions made. 
The key is that an employee who is seen to act reasonably and have decent procedures in place will earn the respect of their employees. Thus the employees will know that there are implications for attending late or taking too many days off sick. This will therefore lead to increased performance and a more contented workforce. Problems can therefore be prevented from happening in the first place.

The above views of those of the author and are not meant as specific advice in relation to any specific employment issue or case. If in doubt, always seek legal advice.

At Chiltern Solicitors we can assist you in relation to all of your staffing and HR issues. For more information on employment law services available please contact us at info@chilternsolicitors.co.uk or have a look at our website at www.chilternsolcitors.co.uk.

We have a HR system that has been specifically designed to help small and medium sized businesses manage their staff. For more information give us a call or see our website.

If you have enjoyed this blog or if you have any comments to make upon this blog and your own experiences of the advantages of keeping good records then please leave a comment below.



Tuesday, 19 August 2014

References - should we agree to requests for information


Writing a reference
Writing a reference for an employee seems a perfectly reasonable thing to do. After all, the new potential employer will need to know if the employee turned up late every Monday morning or had a bad attitude to female colleagues. On the other hand, the new employer may want confirmation that their new employee is a star in the making and that you are very sad to be potentially losing him.

What are the potential problems
It is important that any reference is true and accurate. It may be that the employee was late every Monday morning. However, the author of the reference may not have known that the employee's supervisor had allowed this and a shortened lunch break so that the employee could drop off his or her son at school.

In writing a reference there is both a duty to the new employer and the previous employee. If you make a false statement you could be sued for damages by the employee if he or she is not successful in obtaining their desired new role.

Again, the same is true if an employee is described in glowing terms by his previous employer as they are glad to see the back of him. However, the truth is that he is lazy and has a bad attitude. Further, he is a disruptive influence and has been disciplined a countless occasions. In this case the new employer may seek to sue the old employer for damages based upon the fact that they have taken on a new employee who they would never had employed had they known all of the facts of his previous employment.

Requests for a reference
Most employers deal with requests in one of three ways. The first way is to refuse to give any type of reference. This is not particularly helpful to anyone. Further, most employers seek information by way of references and therefore they should feel able to meet any requests in a positive way.

The second way of dealing with references is to send a standard reference giving such details as job title, dates of employment, salary and sickness record. Again, this is of limited assistance to the new employer and may not help the employee in his search for new employment.

The third and final way of dealing with requests is to give a full reference and provide all information requested. It is important that the reference is prepared by a person with authority to write the reference on behalf of the company and even more importantly is aware of the employee and has the knowledge required of the employee to write the reference. If the employee was dismissed then this should be stated and the reasoning behind the dismissal should be explained. If the person left by way of a settlement agreement then this should be so stated.

What steps do we need to take as an employer

  • Have a policy on references and stick to it. Make staff aware of this policy.
  • Make someone in the Company responsible for writing references and ensure that others know that they have no authority to reply to requests on behalf of the Company.
  • If an individual is asked to write a reference then they should do so as an individual and not as a representative of the Company. They should make this clear in the reference that the views expressed are those of the individual and not necessarily the Company.
  • Include a disclaimer with all references excluding any liability for any inaccuracies. However, this will only be over very limited effect.
  • If you wish to adopt a policy of no references or limited references then make it clear that this is your policy for all employees.
  • Be reasonable and be truthful. If you are both then there is little risk in providing references.
  • If you are at all concerned by a request then seek legal advice.     
The above blog represent the views of the author and is not meant to be relied upon as specific legal advice on any particular set of facts. If in doubt always seek legal advice.

At Chiltern Solicitors, we have a HR system to take care of all of your staffing needs. If you have ever struggled to get some quick advice on an employment issue or have failed to find previous notes on a staffing issue then the system is for you. Ever business employing staff will benefit from having advice readily accessible, staff documents kept securely and in order and a telephone helpline. For more information watch the video on our website at www.chilternsolicitors.co.uk or call us on 01582 439795 for a free demonstration and to discuss how the system can be set up to help you.  

At Chiltern Solicitors we are experts in employment and staffing issues. For regular updates on employment law issues sign up on our website. www.chilternsolicitors.co.uk or email us at info@chilternsolicitors.co.uk 




Friday, 8 August 2014

What is the difference between misconduct and gross misconduct

Many employers struggle to understand the difference between misconduct and gross misconduct. However, it is important that this is dealt with properly by employers. After all, an employer is entitled to dismiss without giving notice to an employee is they are deemed to be guilty of gross misconduct. This will not apply to a case of simple misconduct where dismissal will still apply but notice is required to be given to the employee.

What amounts to misconduct
The law does not define misconduct. However, over time, certain issues have been identified as amounting to misconduct. We have outlined a few examples below:

  • theft or dishonesty
  • violence or fighting
  • unauthorised absence
  • disobedience
  • misuse of internet/social media
  • being under the influence of alcohol/drugs
  • harassment of staff/customers
  • behaviour which undermines good faith in the employee
What amounts to gross misconduct
Again there is no definition of what amounts to gross misconduct or indeed what the difference is between misconduct and gross misconduct. Generally speaking, the more serious the act of misconduct, the more likely it is that an employer will be entitled to rely upon a finding of gross misconduct. Virtually all of the examples given above can amount to misconduct or gross misconduct and will have to be viewed on a case by case basis. We have however given some examples below as to how the facts of a particular case may influence what decision an employer may reach.

Theft
A minor theft such as taking a colleague's chocolate bar may be seen as misconduct rather than gross misconduct. However, if the employee works with money or in a position involving a high degree of trust then any act of dishonesty may affect how the employer perceives the employee and may lead them to find that the act does amount to gross misconduct.

Violence
An act of violence in the workplace will always rightly be viewed as being serious. However, what if the act of violence takes place outside of the workplace. For example an employee may be cautioned by the police for a minor assault whilst out drinking. If this is the case then other issues will come into consideration such as any adverse publicity and the role in question. For example, a window cleaner may escape dismissal in such a case whereas a carer or social worker who works with vulnerable people may be dealt with very differently.

Misuse of social media
Again this is a question of degree and, to some extent common sense. An employee using facebook or twitter on work's time would not normally face summary dismissal. However, if the same employee was using social media to harass a colleague or make inappropriate remarks about his employer then he may face dismissal.

What does this mean to your business?
Any business must know what amounts to misconduct and what amounts to gross misconduct when dealing with disciplinary issues. Get it wrong and you will face a claim for unfair dismissal with awards averaging between £5-10k. Far better to seek an hour's legal advice so you are aware of your options and how to deal with matters properly and effectively. 

Summary
If dealing with misconduct issues, investigate thoroughly and establish the facts then consider the following points:
  • How have others been dealt with for similar matters
  • What is the effect upon the business
  • What is the effect upon other employees
  • Has trust and confidence in the employee been affected
  • If the matter took place away from the workplace is this a relevant issue in how the matter is viewed
This blog contains the views of the author and is not intended to be specific legal advice on any particular set of facts. If in doubt then always seek legal advice.

At Chiltern Solicitors we are experts in providing workplace solutions to your staffing issues. Call us on 01582 439795 or email us at info@chilternsolicitors.co.uk. Please take a look at our website at www.chilternsolicitors.co.uk

Thursday, 7 August 2014

Why employing staff is a little like running a car

When you first read this headline it makes little if any sense. However, employing staff is very much like running a car and the same principles can be applied to both. We all know that when your car has problems the bills involved can be very large indeed. This also applies to your business if you fail to deal with  staffing issues in the correct way.

An employer who got things wrong which costs the Company £10k
There are many examples we could give of Companies getting staffing issues badly wrong. However, a recent case  we will discuss involves a bus driver in the Tamworth. Mr Blower was employed by a local Company and was on sick leave, suffering from arthritis and diabetes. Whilst he was on sick leave he received a letter from his employer stating that he had been sacked.

Mr Blower took his employer to Birmingham Employment Tribunal and won his case for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination. The employer was ordered to pay him £10k in compensation after both claims were successful.

Where did the employer go wrong?
We do not know all of the facts but it appears that a letter was sent to the employee just dismissing him. It does not appear that the employer considered having a meeting with the employee to discuss matters. It may have been open to the employer to employ the driver in a different role or make reasonable adjustments to his driving role. It may have been possible for the Company to consider a health related dismissal based upon capability grounds. However, it appears that the employer may have just sent the dismissal letter.

How could the employer have dealt with things differently?
At this stage, we come back to our comparison  of a business and a car. Most of us are capable of dealing with simple day to day maintenance with a car. With a little bit of guidance and common sense, we can check the oil, tyre pressures and top up the radiator. However, when the service light comes on we don't go to the garage and reach for the tool box as most of us simply don't have the skills or knowledge involved.

In a business, most of us can deal with the simple staffing issues such as holiday entitlement, an application to leave early and even minor issues relating to performance. However, when the 'service light' comes on in the business such as an employee being absent and the matter needing to be dealt with, many employers do not have the knowledge to deal with the matter correctly. This was certainly the case here and the cost to the Company was £10k.

What can we do as an employer?
As mentioned above, most employers should be capable of straightforward day to day maintenance of their business and any staffing issues. However, if matters are more complicated then the employer needs to recognise that the 'service light' has come on and that help from a solicitor or HR advisor needs to be sought. Your car works better if it receives the servicing it needs when required. Your business is no different. If staffing matters are dealt with effectively and correctly then staff are likely to be happier and more importantly there will be no nasty £10k surprises.  

The above views are those of the author and should not be relied upon in relation to any specific legal matter. If in doubt always seek legal advice.

At Chiltern Solicitors, we are experts in proving HR support. Please see our website at www.chilternsolicitors.co.uk for more details or call us on 01582 439795. To receive regular updates on employment and staffing issues email us at info@chilternsolicitors.co.uk.